Schilling

[SF Kid]

Do you think this guy is a hall of fame pitcher? I don't.

[McCovey]

I do. :D

[McCovey]

I think Schilling's career is HoF Fame caliber but not inner circle of course.

216-146, .597 W%, 3.46 ERA, 127 ERA+

Schilling had several huge seasons. Check out his '97, '98, ,01, '02, '04 plus several other really really good seasons. He also had three 300 strikeout seasons. I think only Nolan Ryan and Randy Johnson have more. Also, Schilling was a big time post season performer winning three World Series. In 19 post season starts (133.1 innings) he was

11-2, 2.36 ERA, 4 CG, 120 K, 25 BB

At least to me Schilling was a "winner".

http://www.baseball-reference.com/s/schilcu01.shtml

[Bear]

Do you think this guy is a hall of fame pitcher? I don't.

Schilling is a Hall of Fame pitcher but I hate to see it happen. I have never liked the guy or wanted him to pitch for my team. That being said He has had a great career and had some wonderful post seasons. I would be shocked if he was not voted in on the first ballot.:eek:

[SF Kid]

That is part of the problem. The guy is not likable. He's a real arrogant guy. What a dick.

I just don't think 216 wins is enough to get him into the Hall of Fame -- plus being a dick. :p

[McCovey]

That is part of the problem. The guy is not likable. He's a real arrogant guy. What a dick.

I just don't think 216 wins is enough to get him into the Hall of Fame -- plus being a dick. :p
Well, if "dicks" were not allowed in the HoF then the Hall would have about six members. :p

[SF Kid]

Well, it's got to be factored in in Schllings case. He's a Class I dick to be sure. :pound: